The recently passed Online News Act, also known as Bill C-18, requires tech giants like Google and Meta to negotiate deals with Canadian media companies for the right to link to their Canadian content. However, these tech giants have refused to comply, claiming that they do not value the right to link. Instead, they have decided to block access to Canadian news content on their platforms when the law comes into effect. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau argues that this argument is flawed and dangerous to democracy and the economy, emphasizing the importance of local journalism and understanding current events.
Bill C-18 has been seen as a blow against censorship. The mainstream media and big tech have frequently banned or censored content that they deem undesirable. Platforms like YouTube, owned by Google, have even banned discussions that go against the conventional wisdom, such as Robert Kennedy Jr’s views on vaccines. Mainstream media has also prohibited criticism of vaccines and alternative COVID therapies. This enforcement of government orthodoxy extends to other areas like climate change and gender issues. Those who challenge the conventional wisdom often face cancellation or bans from social media platforms.
By refusing to comply with Bill C-18, big tech companies may unintentionally level the playing field for smaller, independent media outlets that dare to speak truth to power. However, it should be noted that the “Code of Ethics” provision in the bill excludes media organizations that do not align with government narratives, potentially limiting the benefits for independent outlets.
In conclusion, Bill C-18 challenges censorship both within the government and media. It remains to be seen how the refusal of big tech companies to comply will impact the media landscape.